, ,

Should Nurses Work at Home Before Emigrating? 6 Arguments in the Japa Debate

Nurse emigration is draining health systems in Nigeria and beyond. Should nurses be required to work at home first? 6 arguments on both sides.

·

·

4–6 minutes

·

Edited by Joshua Adebanjo, RN

nurse emigration

Every year, tens of thousands of nurses leave Nigeria, Ghana, Zimbabwe, Kenya, India and the Philippines for better pay and conditions in the UK, the US, Canada, the Gulf and Australia. Health systems at home are left struggling. Should countries require nurses to work locally for a set period before they can emigrate, or is that an unfair restriction on their rights?

This debate looks at nurse emigration, the 2024 controversy over Nigeria’s verification guidelines, 6 arguments for and against compulsory service, and alternatives that might keep nurses without forcing them.

nurse emigration

Imagine you have just qualified as a nurse in Nigeria. Your salary barely covers transport, your ward has one nurse for 30 patients, and your friends abroad send pictures of their new cars. You pass your exams for the UK. Then a new rule says you must work two years at home before your certificate can be verified. You feel betrayed. Your hospital manager, struggling to staff her wards, feels relieved.

The scale of nurse emigration

Nurse emigration has accelerated since the COVID-19 pandemic, as high-income countries recruit actively to fill their own shortages. The WHO publishes a health workforce support and safeguards list of countries, many in Africa, where active recruitment is discouraged because their own shortages are severe. Yet nurses from these countries continue to move, often through direct applications.

Nigeria’s verification guidelines controversy

In February 2024, the Nursing and Midwifery Council of Nigeria announced revised guidelines for verifying certificates for nurses seeking to work abroad, including a requirement for at least two years of post-qualification experience. Nurses protested, lawmakers called for the guidelines to be suspended, and a group of nurses went to court to challenge them. The episode became a flashpoint in Nigeria’s wider “japa” debate about emigration.

The case for compulsory service before nurse emigration

  • Return on public investment. Many nurses are trained in subsidised public schools; citizens expect some service in return.
  • Patient safety at home. Severe staff shortages mean patients die from preventable causes.
  • Experience. Two years of practice makes new nurses safer and more confident wherever they go.
  • Precedent. Some countries require doctors or other professionals to serve locally or in rural areas after training.

The case against restricting nurse emigration

  • Human rights. People have the right to leave their country and seek better work.
  • Root causes. Nurses leave because of poor pay, unsafe conditions, insecurity and lack of career growth. Restrictions do not fix these.
  • Unfair burden. Nurses are singled out while other professionals and politicians face no such rules.
  • Brain waste. Forcing nurses to stay without jobs or fair pay may push them out of nursing entirely.
  • Remittances. Nurses abroad send money home that supports families and economies.

Countries that have tried restrictions

Approach Example
Deployment caps The Philippines limited the number of nurses leaving each year during the COVID-19 pandemic
Bonding for public scholarships Several countries require service after state-funded training
Experience requirements Nigeria’s 2024 guidelines proposed two years before verification
Bilateral agreements Government-to-government recruitment deals that share benefits

Alternatives to forcing nurses to stay

  • raising salaries and paying them on time;
  • improving safety, staffing and equipment;
  • offering housing, transport and rural allowances;
  • creating career pathways and specialist training;
  • training more nurses, including for export, with agreements that compensate source countries;
  • encouraging circular migration, where nurses return with new skills.

What it means for nurses

If you plan to emigrate, keep up to date with your nursing council’s rules, keep copies of your documents, and seek information from official sources rather than social media rumours. Consider gaining solid clinical experience at home first; it often makes the transition abroad easier and safer.

The human side of nurse emigration

For individual nurses, leaving home is rarely simple. Many leave behind children, ageing parents and support networks. Some face racism, loneliness and deskilling abroad, working as carers while waiting for registration. Others thrive, earn far more and send money home that pays school fees and builds houses. Nurse emigration is both a personal journey and a national issue.

What source countries are trying

  • bilateral agreements with destination countries that include training support;
  • retention allowances for rural and hard-to-staff posts;
  • expanding nursing school places;
  • faster payment of salaries and arrears;
  • diaspora programmes that encourage nurses abroad to teach, mentor or return.

What destination countries could do

Critics argue that rich countries benefit from nurse emigration without paying for training. They suggest compensation funds, investment in nursing schools in source countries, and limiting active recruitment from countries on the WHO safeguards list.

Nurse emigration and patient safety at home

When experienced nurses leave, wards are often staffed by new graduates without senior support. Maternal and newborn care, intensive care and theatres are particularly affected. This is why many nursing leaders say nurse emigration must be managed, not ignored.

Frequently asked questions

Is nurse emigration illegal?

No. Emigration is legal, but councils control verification of certificates and good standing letters.

Does experience help with jobs abroad?

Yes. Many employers prefer or require post-qualification experience.

Will restrictions stop the brain drain?

Most experts say restrictions alone will not work without better pay and conditions.

But isn’t it selfish for nurses to leave?

Many nurses say staying would be the selfless choice if they could survive on their pay and work safely. Others argue professionals owe something to the country that trained them. Nurse emigration is less a question of selfishness than of a system that has not given nurses enough reason to stay.

Your next step: Should nurses be required to work at home for two years before emigrating? Share your view in the comments, especially if you are planning to japa or have already left.

Related: International recruitment and brain drain · ECOWAS plan to retain health workers · Repayment clauses debate

Sources: WHO health workforce support and safeguards list; Nairametrics: two-year rule announced; Nairametrics: House of Representatives halts guidelines.

Joshua Ibukunoluwa Adebanjo

Founder & Editor-in-Chief

Joshua Ibukunoluwa Adebanjo

RN, RM, RPHN, BNSc (Obafemi Awolowo University)

Joshua is a registered nurse, midwife and public health nurse with clinical experience at Obafemi Awolowo University Teaching Hospitals Complex. He founded Nursing Media Network to give nurses worldwide trustworthy news, career guidance and a stronger public voice, and leads its editorial direction.

Full profile · Editorial policy · joshuadebanjo.com

Health information on Nursing Media Network is for education and does not replace advice from your own nurse or healthcare provider.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Nursing Media Network

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading