, ,

Should Families Provide Bedside Care in Hospitals? 6 Arguments on Both Sides

In many hospitals, relatives cook, wash and watch over patients. Is that a strength or a failure of nursing care? 6 arguments on both sides.

·

·

4–6 minutes

·

Edited by Joshua Adebanjo, RN

family caregivers in hospitals

In hospitals across Nigeria, India, Ghana, Bangladesh, Ethiopia and many other countries, relatives stay at the bedside day and night. They wash patients, feed them, buy medicines, run to the lab and sleep on the floor. In other countries, families visit for a few hours and nurses do almost everything. Should family caregivers in hospitals be welcomed as partners, or is their role a sign of failing health systems?

This debate looks at why family caregivers in hospitals are common, 6 arguments for and against, the risks for patients and relatives, and how nurses can work with families fairly.

family caregivers in hospitals

Imagine your father is admitted to a general hospital after a stroke. The nurse tells you there are only two nurses for the whole ward tonight. You stay, sleeping on a mat beside his bed, turning him, feeding him through the night and buying his medicines from the pharmacy outside. You are exhausted, but you know he would be neglected without you. A week later, you wonder: is this how it should be?

Why family caregivers in hospitals are so common

  • severe shortages of nurses and care assistants;
  • patients paying for medicines and supplies out of pocket, so someone must buy them;
  • hospital food not provided or not culturally suitable;
  • strong cultural expectations that family cares for the sick;
  • fear that patients will be neglected or mistreated without family present.

The case for family caregivers in hospitals

  • Comfort. Familiar faces reduce fear, confusion and loneliness, especially for older people and children.
  • Extra eyes. Relatives often notice changes early and alert nurses.
  • Delirium prevention. Family presence can reduce confusion in older patients.
  • Preparation for home. Relatives learn how to care for the patient after discharge.
  • Cultural fit. In many societies, caring for the sick is a family duty and source of dignity.

The case against relying on families

  • Hidden understaffing. When families fill gaps, governments and hospitals may avoid employing enough nurses.
  • Unequal care. Patients without family, or whose family must work, may receive less care.
  • Safety risks. Untrained relatives may lift patients unsafely, give food to people who cannot swallow, or give traditional remedies.
  • Infection. Crowded wards with many relatives increase infection risk.
  • Burden on relatives. Families lose income, sleep and health, and women carry most of the load.

Family-centred care vs family-dependent care

Family-centred care Family-dependent care
Families choose to be involved Families are required to provide basic care
Nurses remain responsible for care Care falls on whoever is present
Relatives are taught and supported Relatives learn by trial and error
Open visiting with rest for families Relatives stay day and night without facilities

Many high-income countries now encourage open visiting and family involvement, recognising its benefits, while keeping nurses responsible for care.

How nurses can work well with family caregivers in hospitals

  • Welcome relatives and explain the ward routine.
  • Teach safe moving, feeding and hygiene where relatives want to help.
  • Be clear about tasks only staff should do, such as giving medicines.
  • Ask relatives what they have noticed and listen.
  • Check that patients without family receive the same care.
  • Remember relatives need rest, food and kindness too.

What would help

Safer staffing, free essential medicines on wards, hospital meals, family rest areas and clear guidance on what relatives can and cannot do would allow families to support patients by choice rather than necessity.

The hidden cost to family caregivers in hospitals

Relatives who stay at the bedside often lose income, miss school or work, sleep on floors or chairs, and eat poorly. Many are women: wives, daughters and mothers. Some become unwell themselves from exhaustion or infections picked up on the ward. Studies in several countries have found that family caregivers in hospitals spend large amounts on food, transport, medicines and supplies, pushing households into poverty.

Children in hospital

For children, a parent’s presence is widely recognised as essential. Parents comfort children, help with feeding and notice changes quickly. Children’s wards in many countries now provide beds or chairs for parents. The debate is less about whether parents should stay and more about whether they should be expected to do nursing tasks.

Patients without family

Older people living alone, migrants, homeless people and abandoned patients may have no one to stay with them. On wards that rely on family caregivers in hospitals, these patients risk being neglected. Nurses must make sure they receive equal care, which is only possible with safe staffing.

Training family caregivers in hospitals

Some hospitals run short sessions for relatives on hand hygiene, safe feeding, preventing falls and pressure sores, and recognising warning signs. This can improve safety and prepare families for care at home.

Frequently asked questions

Can I refuse to stay with my relative in hospital?

You should be able to. The hospital remains responsible for care, though in practice staffing may be stretched.

Should relatives give medicines?

No. Medicines should be given by nurses to ensure the right dose and timing.

Is family presence good for children?

Yes. Parents staying with children in hospital is strongly encouraged in most countries.

But aren’t families the best people to care for their own?

Families bring love, comfort and knowledge that no nurse can replace. The problem is when families have no choice because wards are dangerously understaffed. The goal for many is care where family caregivers in hospitals are partners, not substitutes for nurses.

Your next step: Have you stayed with a relative in hospital or worked on a ward full of family caregivers? Share your experience in the comments: support or a sign of a failing system?

Related: Safe staffing and nurse-patient ratios · Delirium · Family presence during resuscitation

Sources: WHO: nursing and midwifery; Institute for Patient- and Family-Centered Care.

Joshua Ibukunoluwa Adebanjo

Founder & Editor-in-Chief

Joshua Ibukunoluwa Adebanjo

RN, RM, RPHN, BNSc (Obafemi Awolowo University)

Joshua is a registered nurse, midwife and public health nurse with clinical experience at Obafemi Awolowo University Teaching Hospitals Complex. He founded Nursing Media Network to give nurses worldwide trustworthy news, career guidance and a stronger public voice, and leads its editorial direction.

Full profile · Editorial policy · joshuadebanjo.com

Health information on Nursing Media Network is for education and does not replace advice from your own nurse or healthcare provider.

Leave a Reply

Most read

Discover more from Nursing Media Network

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading