,

Duty to Care in Epidemics: 10 Arguments For and Against Nurses Refusing Unsafe Work

Can nurses refuse to work in epidemics without protection? Both sides of the duty to care debate.

·

·

8–13 minutes

·

Edited by Joshua Adebanjo, RN

duty to care

When epidemics strike, nurses are on the front line, and many pay with their lives.

But is the duty to care absolute? Can a nurse refuse to treat patients when there is no protective equipment, no pay and no support? This question became painfully real during Ebola and COVID-19, and it is returning with every new outbreak.

duty to care

Imagine a nurse in a district hospital when a suspected Ebola patient arrives. The isolation ward has a few pairs of gloves, no full gowns and no running water. Salaries have not been paid for three months. The nurse has two children at home. Her manager says it is her duty to care. Her husband begs her not to go in. She stands at the door of the ward, gloves in hand, and has to decide.

Why the Duty to care debate is heating up

Health workers face greatly increased risks during epidemics. During the West African Ebola epidemic of 2014 to 2016, WHO reported that hundreds of health workers were infected and more than 500 died. During the COVID-19 pandemic, WHO estimated that between 80,000 and 180,000 health and care workers may have died from COVID-19 between January 2020 and May 2021.

Many nurses worked without adequate personal protective equipment, sometimes buying their own masks or reusing single-use items. Some faced stigma in their communities, violence from frightened patients and families, and inadequate compensation when they fell ill.

These experiences raised hard questions about the limits of the duty to care. Professional codes emphasise nurses’ responsibility to patients, but they also recognise nurses’ rights to safe working conditions. Where those two collide, nurses are left with impossible choices.

New outbreaks keep testing these questions. Recent Ebola, mpox and cholera outbreaks have again put nurses in difficult positions, especially where salaries are delayed and supplies are short. Each time, nurses ask whether lessons from COVID-19 have really been learned.

How the the duty to care in epidemics debate began

Nurses have cared for patients during epidemics for centuries, from plague and cholera to influenza and HIV. Many died doing so. Their courage became part of nursing’s identity and public image.

The HIV epidemic of the 1980s brought a new debate when some health workers refused to treat patients with HIV out of fear. Professional bodies responded by stating that refusing care based on a patient’s diagnosis was unethical, while stressing the importance of standard precautions.

The SARS outbreak of 2003, Ebola in 2014 to 2016 and COVID-19 brought the issue back. Nurses’ organisations argued that the duty to care must be matched by employers’ and governments’ duty to protect. The International Council of Nurses has repeatedly called for adequate protective equipment, fair pay and recognition for nurses working in outbreaks.

The case for a strong duty to care in epidemics

Patients depend on nurses most in crises

When epidemics strike, patients need care urgently, and nurses are often the only professionals available. Supporters argue that the duty to care is at its strongest when patients are most vulnerable. Abandoning patients in an outbreak could lead to many more deaths. In the first days of an outbreak, a single nurse who stays at her post can be the difference between a contained cluster and a wave of deaths.

Nursing is a profession with special obligations

Nurses choose a profession that involves caring for sick people, including those with infectious diseases. Supporters argue that this choice includes accepting some level of risk, similar to firefighters or police officers. People choose nursing knowing it involves contact with illness, and many see that knowledge as part of the commitment they made.

Refusal can spread fear and stigma

If nurses refuse to treat patients with a particular disease, it can increase public fear and stigma. Supporters argue that nurses’ willingness to care reassures communities and helps contain outbreaks. When the people trusted most by communities refuse to approach a patient, panic and rumour can spread faster than the virus itself.

Professional codes stress responsibility

Codes of ethics describe nurses’ responsibility to provide care respectfully and without discrimination. Supporters argue that the duty to care cannot be switched off when conditions become difficult. Patients in an epidemic are frightened, isolated and often dying, and the codes were written precisely for moments like these.

History shows nurses make the difference

Supporters point out that in many outbreaks, nurses’ commitment saved countless lives and helped end epidemics. They see the duty to care as central to nursing’s proud legacy. Stories of nurses who stayed through cholera, plague and Ebola remain some of the most powerful examples of what the profession stands for.

The case for a right to refuse unsafe work

Duty to care is reciprocal

Opponents argue that nurses’ duty to care must be matched by employers’ and governments’ duty to provide protective equipment, training, fair pay and support. If those duties are not met, nurses cannot be expected to risk their lives. A promise that runs only one way is not a fair promise, and nurses should not carry every risk alone.

Nurses have families and their own lives

Nurses who become infected can pass diseases to their families. Opponents argue that expecting nurses to risk not only themselves but also their children and elderly parents without protection is unjust. A nurse who becomes infected may bring the disease home to a newborn, a pregnant partner or a grandparent.

Dead nurses cannot care for anyone

Opponents argue that protecting nurses is essential for patient care. If nurses become ill or die because they lacked protection, fewer nurses are left to care for patients. Refusing unsafe work can be a way to protect the long-term capacity of the health system. An epidemic that kills nurses early leaves hospitals without the staff they need for the long months ahead.

Exploitation is not heroism

Opponents argue that praising nurses as heroes can mask governments’ failure to protect them. Refusal to work without protection can be a powerful protest that forces authorities to act. Calling nurses heroes costs nothing, while masks, gowns and fair pay cost real money.

Labour law often recognises the right to refuse

In many countries, workers have a legal right to refuse work that poses serious and imminent danger. The ILO Occupational Safety and Health Convention, 1981 (No. 155) recognises workers’ right to remove themselves from danger. Opponents argue that nurses should not be excluded from these protections. Firefighters are not sent into burning buildings without breathing apparatus, and many nurses ask why they should be treated differently.

What the duty to care in epidemics means for patients and nurses

For patients, nurses’ willingness to care during epidemics can be life-saving. But patients also benefit when nurses are protected, because healthy nurses can keep working and are less likely to spread infections.

For nurses, the duty to care in epidemics is deeply personal. Many feel strong moral obligations to their patients, while also fearing for their own safety and their families. Moral distress, burnout and trauma are common after outbreaks.

For employers and governments, the challenge is to ensure that nurses never face the choice between abandoning patients and risking their lives without protection. That requires planning, stockpiles of protective equipment, training, fair pay and support for those who fall ill.

For communities, how nurses are treated during and after epidemics affects trust in the health system. Stigma against health workers, seen in some outbreaks, can make the situation worse.

For nursing students and newly qualified nurses, outbreaks can be especially frightening. Clear guidance on what they can and cannot be asked to do helps protect them while they are still learning.

What the evidence says about the duty to care in epidemics

Studies of nurses during epidemics consistently show high levels of fear, stress and moral distress. Research from COVID-19 found that lack of protective equipment, inadequate training and poor communication were major sources of stress and intention to leave.

Evidence also shows that adequate protective equipment and infection prevention training significantly reduce health worker infections. During Ebola, infections among health workers fell when infection prevention measures improved.

Ethical analyses of the duty to care conclude that it is real but not unlimited, and that reciprocity, meaning support and protection from employers and society, is essential.

Duty to care around the world

Health workers in many low- and middle-income countries faced the greatest risks during Ebola and COVID-19, often with severe shortages of protective equipment and unpaid salaries. In some cases, nurses went on strike to demand protection and pay.

In high-income countries, shortages of protective equipment early in the COVID-19 pandemic led to protests and legal actions by nurses’ unions. Some countries introduced compensation schemes for health workers who died or were seriously harmed.

WHO, ICN and the International Labour Organization have emphasised the need to protect health workers in emergencies, including through national preparedness plans.

5 questions to ask yourself about the duty to care in epidemics

  1. Would you treat a patient with a deadly infectious disease without proper protection?
  2. What should employers owe you in return for your duty to care?
  3. Should refusal ever be considered abandonment?
  4. How should nurses who fall ill in outbreaks be compensated?
  5. What did you learn from COVID-19 about the limits of the duty to care?

Is there a middle way on the duty to care in epidemics?

A middle way recognises that nurses have a strong duty to care during epidemics, but that this duty is conditional on reasonable protection and support. Nurses should not abandon patients without handover, but they should have the right to refuse work that poses serious, unmitigated risk to life.

Employers and governments should be legally required to provide adequate protective equipment, training, fair pay, insurance and mental health support for health workers in outbreaks.

Clear national policies could set out what nurses can expect and what they can refuse, reducing uncertainty and moral distress.

Recognition matters too, not only applause but practical recognition in pay, compensation and memorials for those who died.

Nurses’ voices must be part of preparedness planning. Those who worked through past outbreaks know exactly what support is needed, and their experience can prevent the same mistakes being repeated.

Free checklist: protecting yourself in an outbreak

Use this free checklist when your workplace prepares for an infectious disease outbreak.

  • Know your infection prevention protocols.
  • Check the availability of protective equipment before you need it.
  • Request training on donning and doffing.
  • Know your rights under local labour and health and safety laws.
  • Ask about compensation if you become ill at work.
  • Look after your mental health and seek support early.

Where do you stand on the duty to care in epidemics?

Is the duty to care absolute in epidemics, or can nurses refuse unsafe work? Start your comment with ABSOLUTE DUTY or RIGHT TO REFUSE and tell us what you experienced during COVID-19 or other outbreaks.

Thousands of nurses read Nursing Media Network every week. When you add your voice, with your country and your role, you help other nurses see how this issue plays out far beyond their own ward. Disagree respectfully, share your experience rather than attacking people, and remember that patient confidentiality applies in the comments too.

But won’t patients die if nurses refuse?

Sometimes they may. That is why the duty to care is so painful in outbreaks. But patients also die when nurses are infected, burned out or killed because they lacked protection. The strongest response is to make refusal unnecessary by protecting nurses properly from the start. Protection is not a reward for courage; it is the condition that makes courage possible.

Your next step: Find out this week what outbreak preparedness plan your workplace has, and where protective equipment is stored. Knowing in advance makes a real difference.

Related: Congo Ebola deaths and unpaid health workers · Violence against nurses in 2026 · Should nurses be allowed to strike? · Mandatory vaccination for nurses

Sources: WHO: health and care worker deaths during COVID-19; International Council of Nurses.

Joshua Ibukunoluwa Adebanjo

Founder & Editor-in-Chief

Joshua Ibukunoluwa Adebanjo

RN, RM, RPHN, BNSc (Obafemi Awolowo University)

Joshua is a registered nurse, midwife and public health nurse with clinical experience at Obafemi Awolowo University Teaching Hospitals Complex. He founded Nursing Media Network to give nurses worldwide trustworthy news, career guidance and a stronger public voice, and leads its editorial direction.

Full profile · Editorial policy · joshuadebanjo.com

Health information on Nursing Media Network is for education and does not replace advice from your own nurse or healthcare provider.

Leave a Reply

Most read

Discover more from Nursing Media Network

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading